Health Insurance

The City of St. Marys health insurance carrier is Medical Mutual.  Employees have the ability to pick between two plans:  a PPO plan and an HSA plan.  Our broker is Stolly Insurance Group. Representatives from Stolly's are available to assist employees with questions or concerns regarding health insurance, e.g., health savings account, plan options, prescription benefits, claims issues. Representatives can be reached at 1-800-686-2147.

Medical Mutual is the network provider. An online provider directory is available on Medical Mutual’s web site at or by calling 1-800-272-6967. It’s always best to verify with the doctor’s office whether or not they are participating in the network since the network changes frequently. To receive maximum benefits at the lowest out-of-pocket expense, covered services must be provided by a network provider. Network and non-network deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket limits are separate and do not accumulate toward each other.

The address for claims is:  Medical Mutual of Ohio, P.O. Box 94648, Cleveland, OH  44101-4648

The health insurance effective date for new hires is the beginning of the month following the date of employment.